Authorities in Singapore have seized more than 14 tons of scales of pangolin scales bound for Vietnam in what Paul Thomson of the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s (IUCN) Pangolin Specialist Group described as the largest single such shipment on record, the New York Times reported on Monday. Thomson told the paper that the IUCN estimated around 36,000 pangolins were killed to harvest the scales, which is forbidden by international law.
Pangolins are scaly anteaters poached for both their scales, which are sometimes marketed as a (scientifically unsupported) treatment for various health conditions, as well as their meat, which is considered a delicacy in some regions. The pangolin trade was banned by the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species in 2016, according to the Washington Post. However, domestic trade remains legal in some countries including China, where pangolins are nearly extinct, and Vietnam.
Part of the appeal is the pangolin’s renowned ability to stave off predators, with their scaly, keratin-laden hides protecting them even from large carnivores.
Unfortunately, pangolins do not fare anywhere near as well against humans, who can easily kill or capture them when they curl into a defensive posture. They do poorly in captivity and usually die within months of capture from a host of health problems. (Even those pangolins rescued alive by authorities often still face a grim end, according to the South China Morning Post.)
Virtually all trade in them is thus believed to be tied to the black market. By some estimates, pangolins are the most trafficked mammal in the world, far outstripping elephants by raw numbers. Conservation group WildAid told Reuters it estimates 100,000 are poached from the wild each year.
It’s not clear from the Times report what species of pangolin fell victim to the poaching operation discovered in Singapore; the IUCN Red List, however, classifies all four Asian species as either endangered or critically endangered, while their four African cousins are classified as vulnerable. All populations are listed as decreasing.
Per a WildAid report from 2016:
Their elusive nature has made it difficult to estimate how many still exist in the wild. However, hunters, traders and locals have reported drastic declines in sightings of Asian species across different parts of their range. Interviews with hunters in 2007 and 2011 suggested populations of the Sunda Pangolin in Peninsular Malaysia have fallen dramatically, with 95% of hunters recognizing severe declines, especially since 1990, when the commercial trade began to escalate. The rarity of sightings in the wild, coupled with the massive volume of scales and carcasses seen in trade over the past decade, suggests that all eight species may be on the brink of extinction.
In a joint statement, Singaporean customs and parks officials said the shipment (labeled as “frozen beef”) was intercepted during inspection at Pasir Panjang Export Inspection Station. The officials estimated the massive pile pangolin scales as worth approximately $38.7 million, far outstripping a prior record-breaking bust in China in 2016. Also in the container was around 390 pounds of carved elephant ivory, which officials estimated to be worth an additional $88,500.
“Under the Endangered Species (Import & Export) Act, the maximum penalty for illegal
import, export and re-export of wildlife is a fine of up to $500,000 and/or 2 years’
imprisonment,” Singaporean authorities wrote in the statement. “The same penalties apply to transit or transhipment of illegal wildlife
species, including their parts and derivatives.”
“The Singapore Government adopts a zero-tolerance stance on the use of Singapore as a conduit to smuggle endangered species and their parts and derivatives,” they added. “Our agencies will continue to collaborate and maintain vigilance to tackle the illegal wildlife trade.”
[New York Times]